Studies Could Decide MS Theory's Validity
Preliminary studies have suggested that a phenomenon called Chronic Cerebrospinal Venous Insufficiency (CCSVI), a reported abnormality in blood drainage from the brain and spinal cord, may contribute to nervous system damage in MS. This hypothesis has been put forth by Dr. Paolo Zamboni from the University of Ferrara in Italy who published initial findings in June 2009 from a study of approximately 65 patients. There have been additional studies published since then, some of which showing results that conflict with the original findings. Read more about published studies to date.
National MS Society research leaders first met with Dr. Zamboni in February 2010 at New York University’s Society-funded MS Center of Excellence and again in April when the Society hosted, along with the American Academy of Neurology, a live Web forum on CCSVI. Based on the results of preliminary research which has been published in respected peer journals, Dr. Zamboni and others have recommended larger scale studies to determine if CCSVI may be treated through an endovascular surgical procedure, which involves inserting a tiny balloon or stent into blocked veins in order to improve the flow of blood out of the brain and spinal cord.
Dr. Zamboni suggests that if further evidence supports the link between MS and CCSVI, that its treatment may ultimately add to the arsenal of therapies available for MS. He emphasized the need for more research on his hypothesis, and noted that people with MS should remain on their immunomodulatory therapies as has his wife after her endovascular surgical procedure.
This Lead is Being Pursued
The Society shares in the public urgency to advance the understanding of CCSVI as quickly as possible. In order to pursue new and unanticipated leads in MS, the National MS Society established the Rapid Response Fund. An example of this fund in action is the global outreach and expedited review process that led to the more than $2.4 million which the US Society, in collaboration with the MS Society of Canada, is devoting to the funding of seven initial grants that focus on the role of CCSVI in the MS disease process. Work has already begun on these grants. Read the 18-month progress report from these projects.
The seven new grants were chosen by an international panel of experts for having the greatest potential to quickly and comprehensively determine the significance of CCSVI and its relationship to MS. The chosen projects include an integration of experts drawn from all key relevant disciplines including radiology, vascular surgery and neurology. Bringing together experts across these areas will help to facilitate and speed the understanding of CCSVI in MS.
The new studies will carry out significant steps needed to confirm the phenomenon originally described by Dr. Paolo Zamboni and resolve the questions raised by him and others as to whether CCSVI is a cause of MS or related to MS in some other manner. These studies will also resolve conflicting data from previous research, such as how frequently CCSVI occurs in MS, and how often it occurs in people who do not have MS. If blockages are found, the findings will speed the way to determining whether therapeutic trials to correct them will be helpful in improving or altering MS disease process.
Adding clarity to the relationship between CCSVI and MS is essential in assisting people with MS secure any treatment they may consider. Medical institutions and health care providers require research data confirming the validity, necessity and safety of any procedure they provide, and in their view that data is not yet available as it relates to the relationship between CCSVI and MS.
Global Effort
This funding announcement is only a part of the global effort underway to pursue the CCSVI lead. The MS Society of Italy announced in June 2010 its intentions of supporting a 900,000 euro epidemiology study of CCSVI involving 1500 people with MS, bringing the international commitment of the MS Societies pursuing the CCSVI lead to nearly $3.4 million.
In late November 2011, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) announced intentions to release a Request for Proposals that seeks grant applications from researchers to conduct an early-phase clinical trial in Canada to test the ability of a surgical procedure called balloon venoplasty to improve blood drainage in individuals with MS who have been identified as having CCSVI. Read more The request for research proposals is a collaborative initiative between the CIHR and the MS Society of Canada. A working group which includes members of the seven teams being funded by MS Societies in the U.S. and Canada will provide leadership and advice in the drafting of the protocol for the Phase I/II clinical trials in Canada, and will continue to monitor and analyze the data from the seven studies and other studies related to CCSVI and MS around the world.
It has also been reported that Dr. Zamboni is in the process of developing a randomized clinical trial comparing disease modifying therapy with and without balloon venoplasty with sponsorship from the Italian Government. Also, researchers from the University at Buffalo are undertaking a placebo-controlled trial involving 30 people with relapsing remitting MS, which may ultimately involve more depending on preliminary findings. A trial currently listed in the US clearinghouse registry "clinicaltrials.gov" is in Albany, NY, though it has not yet begun recruiting participants for the study.
The U.S. and Canadian MS Societies are working with the Multiple Sclerosis International Federation and other MS Societies from around the world to ensure coordination of information and to share research data from ongoing work that is underway around the world – further speeding progress.
Learn more:
-
Canadian Government Seeks Proposals for Clinical Trial to Treat CCSVI
– Society’s funded CCSVI researchers are among those advising the agency on protocol strategies - Summary of the 2010 ECTRIMS conference featuring more than 900 scientific presentations covering virtually every aspect of research to stop MS, restore function, and end MS forever. Among these were the latest results from pivotal clinical trials of emerging MS therapies, possible risk factors, underlying disease mechanisms, rehabilitation approaches, CCSVI, and much more
- Over $2.4 Million Committed to Support 7 Initial CCSVI Grants to Determine the Role of CCSVI in MS Disease Process. Read the 18-month progress report from these projects.
- FAQs About Newly Funded CCSVI Grants
- Special Report on CCSVI: Summer 2010 Momentum magazine
- FAQs About CCSVI
- CCSVI Alliance website
- Published Studies To Date
- Peer Review Committee for CCSVI Grant Applications
- Buffalo Study Recruiting Participants
- Summary of the April 14 Web forum "CCSVI and what it could mean to people living with MS," hosted by the National MS Society and the American Academy of Neurology with Dr. Paolo Zamboni, Dr. Robert Zivadinov, Dr. Andrew Common and Dr. Aaron Miller. View the recording, read the transcript (pdf) or watch on YouTube
- Society Leaders Meet with Dr. Zamboni (February 2010)
Recent media coverage:
-
MedPage Today, October 27, 2011. ECTRIMS: Little Support Found for Vascular MS Theory
-
Cardiovascular and Interventional Radiological Society of Europe, Congress Newspaper (excerpt),
Sept. 11, 2011, Debate between Drs. Dake and Reekers: Treatment of CCSVI (.pdf) -
Endovascular Today, July 2011, CCSVI: What We Need to Know Now and in the Future
-
Cardiovascularbusiness.com, July 1, 2011, Angioplasty for MS: Patient-driven, safe, but is it effective?
-
Marketwire.com, June 29, 2011, Canadian Minister of Health Commits to Funding CCSVI Trials
-
Interventional News, June 6, 2011, SIR panel sets CCSVI research agenda
-
Globe and Mail, April 28, 2011, Social Media Changing the Medical Funding Paradigm
-
ABCNews.com, April 19, 2011, Multiple Sclerosis: Studies Probe Role of Clogged Neck Veins
-
Journal of Neurology, early online, April 13, 2011, Chronic cerebrospinal venous insufficiency: Have we found the cause and cure of MS?
-
Internal Medicine News Digital Network, February 16, Conflicting CCSVI Data Lead to Call for New Research, United Message
-
NPR, January 31, Doctor Challenges Cause of MS and Treatment
-
CBC News, December 28, Multiple sclerosis vein opening: a timeline
-
The Canadian Press, December 27, Studies in 2011 could decide MS theory's validity
-
MedscapeCCSVI in Focus at ECTRIMS: New Data but Still Little Clarity
-
MS Society of Canada commits $1 million for CCSVI clinical trial, September 16
-
Canadian Institutes of Health Research make recommendation to the Minister of Health that more research is needed before funding a CCSVI clinical trial. Read more in the August 31 press release or meeting summary
-
Society of Interventional Radiology Supports Research for New MS Treatments, August 26 press release, summary
-
Neurology Now, July/August issue, featuring an overview of the CCSVI controversy
-
The Los Angeles Times, August 2, MS Theory Dealt a Blow by Studies
-
Researchers from the University at Buffalo are undertaking a placebo-controlled trial involving 30 people with relapsing remitting MS, June 29
-
The New York Times, June 28, From MS Patients, Outcry for Unproved Treatment
-
The Canadian Press, June 28, MS patients create own informal experiment, going in droves for unproven therapy
-
CBC The Current, April 14 and April 16, with Anna Marie Tremonti featuring Dr. Zamboni, Dr. Freeman and Mike Augustine, an individual living with MS
-
About.com, April 14 blog by Julie Stachowiak, Ph.D. about the ethical aspects of CCSVI treatment and research
-
The Wall Street Journal, March 25, Thomas M. Burton did a feature on Stanford's halt of their MS stenting program
-
National Post, January 23, Tom Blackwell looked at what is known about CCSVI and what yet needs to be learned